How to choose a commercial printing company

Compare the proof, production, quote and finished work. Here’s what to ask before you place a printing order.

United GMG · Est.1927

What questions should I ask a commercial printer?

Ask about five things: the proof and the files, production and finishing, mailing and personalization, quantity and timing, and samples and support. Use the same questions with each company on your shortlist, and check them off as you compare the answers.

  1. Will we approve a proof? What files do you need?

    Confirm the proof type and requirements for a print-ready PDF with bleed.

  2. What is printed here? Who cuts, folds and binds it?

    Ask which steps happen in-house and which go to another supplier.

  3. Can you mail the finished pieces? Can names, versions or languages change?

    Confirm list preparation, inserting and postage, including nonprofit postage if your organization qualifies.

  4. What is the minimum? When will it ship?

    Get a schedule based on your quantity, finishing and approved files.

  5. Can we see similar work? Who handles questions?

    Request physical samples and a named contact for your job.

What kinds of printing companies are there?

Four, for most jobs. An online print store sells standard sizes, papers and finishes from a menu. A local commercial printer produces the job and works with you directly. A print broker manages your order with a separate printer. A trade printer produces work for other printers and resellers.

Four types of printing supplier and what to confirm
Online print storeLocal commercial printerPrint brokerTrade printer
How it worksChoose from a menu of standard sizes, paper and finishes.Work directly with the company producing the job.A broker manages your order with a separate printer.Produces work for other printers and resellers.
What to confirmProof options, finishing, delivery and mailing.What happens in-house and what goes elsewhere.Who produces each part and resolves problems.Your reseller’s proof, production and delivery arrangements.

Compare the complete job cost. No supplier type is always the least expensive.

Should I use an online printing company or a local printer?

The right route depends on how much your job needs to be specified, checked and coordinated.

Order online when

A standard size and paper work, your files are ready, and the available proof and delivery options suit the job.

Speak to a printer when

You need direct mail, personalized versions, custom finishing, a printed proof or help meeting a deadline.

At United GMG, send us the files and counts; a person quotes the job.

How do I know if a printer is a broker?

A print broker manages your order and has a separate company produce it. To find out, ask who handles each step and who keeps the schedule. A broker can coordinate specialties; a direct printer can reduce the number of companies involved.

Through a broker

  1. Your files
  2. Broker
  3. Production suppliers
  4. Delivery or USPS

With a direct printer

  1. Your files
  2. Printing, finishing & mailing
    Printing equipment on the United GMG production floor
    Printing
    Operator working at the paper folding machine
    Folding
    United GMG envelope inserting line
    Mailing
  3. Delivery or USPS

Illustrative routes; the actual handoffs depend on the job. Print management companies can also coordinate ongoing programs.

How should a fundraiser chair or development director choose a print and mail partner?

Ask whether the printer can enter mail at the nonprofit rate on your organization’s behalf, and whether printing, inserting and mailing happen under one roof. Ask how the list is cleaned before each drop, when the proof arrives and how the schedule is built back from the mail date. Then ask to see an appeal package and a gala invitation.

Six questions for a fundraiser chair to ask a printer, why each matters and what to look for
AskWhy it mattersWhat to look for
Can you enter our mail at the nonprofit rate on our behalf?USPS gives the nonprofit rate to authorized organizations, and it is lower than the commercial rate.A printer that asks for your USPS authorization and tells you whose permit the mail will enter on.
Do printing, inserting and mailing happen under one roof?An appeal is several pieces that have to match: the letter, the reply slip and the envelopes.A plain answer about which steps happen in the building and which are sent out.
How is our list cleaned before each drop?Duplicates and outdated addresses spend postage on mail that reaches no one.Addresses checked, movers updated and duplicates removed before every mailing.
When do we see the proof?The proof is where a wrong name, amount or date is caught.A proof you approve before anything prints, and a named person for corrections.
How is the schedule built from the mail date?An appeal or an invitation has a date it must reach homes by.A schedule worked back from the mail date: files, proof approval, printing, inserting and the drop.
Can we see an appeal package and a gala invitation you produced?Printed pieces show the paper, the folds and the finish better than a description.Appeal packages and invitations you can hold, similar to yours.

How do I compare printing quotes?

Give every printer the same specifications and ask for separate prices at the quantities you’re considering. Then compare line by line: printing, finishing, mailing, postage, setup and proof, and delivery.

The estimate

Six items to check on a printing quote
PrintingPaper, size, sides, ink coverage and quantity.
FinishingCutting, scoring, folding, binding and coatings.
MailingList checks, addressing, inserting, sorting and USPS handoff.
PostageA separate line, with permit and payment arrangements.
Setup & proofInitial charges, versions and reprint charges.
DeliveryDestination, shipping cost and confirmed schedule.

A specification checklist, not a price quote.

5005,00025,000

Example quantities only, not minimums or price breaks.

A roll of USPS Forever stamps beside blank envelopes at United GMG

At United GMG, postage is prepaid at USPS cost, using our permit or yours. Keep it separate from production when comparing totals.

How do I check a printer’s work before I commit?

Three ways. Ask for printed samples of work like yours and handle them. Review a proof of your own job before you approve it, and ask when a printed proof is appropriate. Then visit the plant and ask where each part of your order will be handled.

A printed letter package from United GMG: the letter, its reply form and two envelopes

Printed samples

Handle the paper. Inspect color, folds and finish on work similar to yours.

United GMG team members reviewing a job on a production monitor at the Mount Prospect plant

Your job’s proof

Review the content and specifications before approval. Ask when a printed proof is appropriate.

United GMG facility at 1864 South Elmhurst Road

A plant visit

See the production area and ask where each part of your order will be handled.

The press and bindery floor of United GMG’s early Chicago shop, from the company archive
1927

United GMG has been printing since 1927. Our Mount Prospect facility handles printing, finishing and mailing for Chicago-area and nationwide customers. Every job receives a proof; production starts after approval.

Common questions about choosing a printer

What is commercial printing?

Printing produced for a business or organization: brochures, postcards, catalogs, letters, packaging and other materials.

Can I get a quote before files are final?

Yes. Share the format, quantity, paper, finishing and delivery needs. Changes to those specifications may change the quote.

How long will printing take?

Timing depends on quantity, finishing and approved files. Give the printer your delivery deadline and ask for a confirmed schedule.

How do I shortlist printers near Chicago?

Check fit for your format, proof requirements, mailing and deadline. Review completed projects, then request comparable quotes.

Discuss your printing project.

Send files or a description, quantities, paper preferences and your deadline. Tell us if mailing is part of the job.

Schedule a meeting
847.588.7600

Monday–Friday, 8:30 AM–5 PM

United GMG
1864 S Elmhurst Rd, Mount Prospect, IL 60056
About United GMG

Tell us what you’re printing.

Prefer a separate form? Request an itemized quote.

United GMG historical printing display